OK, here's the deal, I want to buy the new Iphone 4 to replace my 3g, I plan to used the 4 on my existing number and data plan, my wife currently has a non-data AT&T phone. I wanted to give her my old 3g to use for a voice phone and use Wifi when available (not to mention the neat apps that are already installed) Here's the rub, AT&T tells me I will need to get a data plan (even though her phone is not under contract) because ALL IPHONES require a data plan.

They said if I were to take the sim card out of her phone and install it into the old 3g they would immediately recognize it as an Iphone an automatically bill me for a data plan.
My 3g was jailbroken on spirit for 3.1.3, I should have the new 4 in a few weeks so I have some time to figure this all out.
Any and all suggestions are welcome as well as some basic steps or instructions.
Thanks and my apologies if this is listed already someware else on the site!